HP and Canon, both renowned printer brands, each have their strengths, leaving the choice in your hands. HP boasts speed and affordability, making it perfect for offices with high capacity. On the other hand, Canon excels in printing, especially photos, offering vibrant and distinct results.
Their focus on quality is widely praised, making it ideal for photographers who want their memories to be enhanced. Consider your needs and the features you seek: HP for efficiency, Canon for the unique. Both brands offer reliable and strong options, so choose wisely and your printing journey will be prolonged. In this article, we will compare the HP Smart Tank 516 and Canon G3010 based on their design, printing, scanning, and connectivity features.
HP Smart Tank 516 vs Canon G3010 Comparison
| Feature | HP Smart Tank 516 | Canon G3010 |
|---|---|---|
| Design and Build Quality | Compact and sleek design | Bulkier appearance |
| Solid construction for durability | ||
| Small LCD screen with few buttons | Larger LCD screen with more buttons | |
| Printing Quality and Speed | Maximum print resolution: 4800 x 1200 dpi | Maximum print resolution: 4800 x 1200 dpi |
| Black and white print speed: up to 11 ppm | Black and white print speed: approximately 8.8 ppm | |
| Color print speed: up to 5 ppm | Color print speed: 5 ppm | |
| Scanning and Copying Quality and Speed | Maximum optical scanning resolution: up to 1200 x 1200 dpi | Maximum optical scanning resolution: up to 1200 x 1200 dpi |
| Scanning speed (B&W): 21 seconds per page | Scanning speed (B&W): 19 seconds per page | |
| Scanning speed (Color): 23 seconds per page | Scanning speed (Color): 32 seconds per page | |
| Copying speed (B&W): 10 cpm | Copying speed (B&W): 3.5 ipm | |
| Copying speed (Color): 2 cpm | ||
| Printing Cost and Page Yields | Ink system: Refillable ink tanks | Ink system: Individual ink cartridges |
| Page yield (Black): 18,000 pages | Page yield: 7,000 pages | |
| Page yield (Color): 8,000 pages | ||
| Printing cost (Monochrome): 10 paisa per page | Printing cost (Black): 8 paisa per page | |
| Printing cost (Color): 20 paisa per page | Printing cost (Color): 21 paisa per page | |
| Connectivity Features | USB and wireless connections | USB and wireless connections |
| Mobile printing support: HP Smart App | Mobile printing support: Canon Print Inkjet/Selphy app |
Design and Build Quality
The HP Smart Tank 516 and Canon G3010 have different design aesthetics. The HP Smart Tank 516 features a more compact and sleek design, while the Canon G3010 has a bulkier appearance. In terms of build quality, both printers have solid constructions, ensuring durability over time. The HP Smart Tank 516 comes with a small LCD screen with a few physical buttons on the control panel, whereas the Canon G3010 features a larger LCD screen and a more comprehensive set of buttons for convenient operation and access to various printer functions.
Printing Quality and Speed
Both printers offer good printing quality. The HP Smart Tank 516 has a maximum print resolution of up to 4800 x 1200 dpi, while the Canon G3010 also has a maximum print resolution of up to 4800 x 1200 dpi. In terms of printing speed, they are relatively similar, with the HP Smart Tank 516 offering up to 11 ppm for black and white prints and 5 ppm for color prints, and the Canon G3010 providing approximately 8.8 ppm for black and white prints and 5 ppm for color prints.
Scanning and Copying Quality and Speed
The HP Smart Tank 516 and Canon G3010 offer decent scanning and copying quality. They typically have a maximum optical scanning resolution of up to 1200 x 1200 dpi, ensuring clear and detailed scans. In terms of scanning speed, the HP Smart Tank 516 is generally faster, with a scan speed of approximately 21 seconds per page for black and white and 23 seconds per page for color.
The Canon G3010 takes about 19 seconds per page for black and white and 32 seconds per page for color scanning. In terms of copying speed, the HP Smart Tank 516 has a speed of 10 cpm (black) and 2 cpm (color), while the Canon G3010 has a copying speed of 3.5 ipm.
Printing Cost and Page Yields
The HP Smart Tank 516 and Canon G3010 utilize different ink systems, which can affect printing costs and page yields. The HP Smart Tank 516 uses refillable ink tanks, which generally offer more cost-effective printing since you can replenish the ink when needed. The Canon G3010 uses individual ink cartridges, where you replace the entire cartridge when one color runs out.
The page yields can vary, but typically, the HP Smart Tank 516 provides 18,000 pages (black) and 8,000 pages (color), while the Canon G3010 provides a yield of 7,000 pages. Additionally, the printing cost of the HP Smart Tank 516 is 10 paisa per page (monochrome) and 20 paisa per page (color), while the Canon G3010 costs 8 paisa per page (black) and 21 paisa per page (color).
Connectivity Features
Both printers are equipped with almost the same connectivity options. They both come with USB and wireless connections. You can easily connect them to your mobile or computer using USB cables or Wi-Fi. Additionally, both of them support mobile printing through the HP Smart App and Canon Print Inkjet/Selphy app, allowing users to print directly from their smartphones.
Conclusion
Determining whether HP or Canon printers are the best overall depends on individual needs and preferences. Both brands offer reliable printers with competitive features, print quality, and performance.
The HP Smart Tank has good scanning, copying, and printing speed, along with decent connectivity. On the other hand, the Canon G3010 takes a bit more time in scanning, printing, and copying than the HP printer. Try to focus on your needs and priorities while choosing one of them.
FAQs
Which printer is more cost-effective in terms of ink?
Ans: The HP Smart Tank 516 has refillable ink tanks, which can potentially save you money in the long run compared to individual ink cartridges used by the Canon G3010.
Can I print wirelessly with both printers?
Ans: Yes, both the HP Smart Tank 516 and Canon G3010 support wireless connectivity, allowing you to print from your computer, smartphone, or tablet without the need for cables.
Are the scanning and copying features comparable for both printers?
Ans: The HP Smart Tank 516 generally offers faster scanning and copying speeds compared to the Canon G3010. However, it’s important to review the specific features and specifications of each printer to determine which one better suits your scanning and copying needs.
Which printer has a more compact design?
Ans: The HP Smart Tank 516 is known for its compact and sleek design, making it a good option if you have limited space. The Canon G3010 is bulkier in size.
Prabir Mandal is the editor-in-chief of Printer Guru. He is in love with productivity devices, especially printers. His love for printers has made him open this blog where he can share all his knowledge about printers and the experiences he has gathered while using them.
