When selecting an ink tank printer for home or small office use, the HP Smart Tank 584 and Epson EcoTank L3250 are two good options you can consider.
Both offer cost-effective printing solutions, but they differ in various aspects. Let’s compare these two printers to help you choose the best one.
HP Smart Tank 584 vs Epson L3250 Specs Comparison
| Feature | HP Smart Tank 584 | Epson EcoTank L3250 |
|---|---|---|
| Functions | Print, Copy, Scan | Print, Copy, Scan |
| Print Technology | HP Thermal Inkjet | Epson Micro Piezo™ print head |
| Print Resolution | Up to 1200 x 1200 rendered dpi | Up to 5760 x 1440 dpi |
| Print Speed (Black) | Up to 12 ppm | Up to 10 ipm (ISO) / 33 ppm (Draft) |
| Print Speed (Color) | Up to 5 ppm | Up to 5 ipm (ISO) / 15 ppm (Draft) |
| Ink Yield (Black) | Up to 6,000 pages | Up to 8,100 pages |
| Ink Yield (Color) | Up to 8,000 pages | Up to 6,500 pages |
| Connectivity | USB, Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, Self-healing Wi-Fi®, HP Smart App, Apple AirPrint™, Google Cloud Print™, Mopria™ | USB, Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, Epson Smart Panel App, Epson Connect (iPrint, Email Print, Remote Print Driver) |
| Mobile Printing | HP Smart App, Apple AirPrint™, Google Cloud Print™, Mopria™ | Epson Smart Panel App, Epson Connect (iPrint, Email Print, Remote Print Driver) |
| Paper Handling | 100-sheet input tray, 30-sheet output tray, Manual duplex printing, Borderless printing up to 8.5 x 11 in (210 x 297 mm) | 100-sheet input tray, 30-sheet output tray, Manual duplex printing, Borderless printing up to 10 x 15 cm |
| Scanner Type | Flatbed | Flatbed colour image scanner (CIS) |
| Scan Resolution | Up to 1200 x 1200 dpi | Optical: 1200 x 2400 dpi |
| Dimensions (W x D x H) | 434.66 x 580.65 x 259.37 mm | 375 x 347 x 179 mm |
| Weight | 5.03 kg | 3.9 kg |
| Power Consumption | 3.023 watts (ready), 1.096 watt (sleep), 0.109 watts (manual-off) | 12 W (standalone copying), 4.5 W (ready), 0.7 W (sleep), 0.2 W (power off) |
| Warranty | One-year or 30,000 pages limited hardware warranty, whichever is earlier | One-year or 30,000 prints, whichever comes first |
Print Quality & Technology
Epson EcoTank L3250: Utilizes Epson’s Micro Piezo™ print head technology, delivering a high resolution of 5760 x 1440 dpi. This ensures sharp text and vibrant images, making it suitable for both documents and photos.
HP Smart Tank 584: Employs HP’s Thermal Inkjet technology with a resolution of 4800 x 1200 dpi. While slightly lower than Epson’s, it still produces clear and crisp prints suitable for everyday tasks.
Winner- For higher-resolution photo printing, the Epson L3250 has an edge. However, for general document printing, both perform perfectly.
Ink Efficiency & Yield
Epson L3250: Comes with ink bottles yielding up to 8,100 pages in black and 6,500 pages in color.
HP Smart Tank 584: Provides ink for up to 6,000 black pages and 8,000 color pages.
Winner: HP offers a higher color page yield, while Epson provides more black and white pages.
Print Speed
Epson L3250: Offers impressive speeds of up to 33 pages per minute (ppm) for black and 15 ppm for color in draft mode.
HP Smart Tank 584: Delivers up to 12 ppm for black and 5 ppm for color prints.
Winner: Epson leads in print speed, beneficial for high-volume printing needs.
Connectivity & Mobile Printing
Epson L3250: Supports USB, Wi-Fi, and Wi-Fi Direct. Compatible with Epson Connect, allowing printing via iPrint, Email Print, and Remote Print Driver.
HP Smart Tank 584: Features USB, Wi-Fi, and self-healing Wi-Fi®. Compatible with HP Smart App, Apple AirPrint™, Google Cloud Print™, and Mopria™.
Winner: Both printers offer robust connectivity options, but HP’s self-healing Wi-Fi® ensures a more stable connection.
Ink Efficiency & Yield
HP Smart Tank 584: Comes with ink bottles yielding up to 6,000 pages for black and 8,000 pages for color prints.
Epson EcoTank L3250: Includes ink bottles capable of printing up to 8,100 pages in black and 6,500 pages in color.
Winner: Epson L3250 is the clear winner here with its high page yield.
Which One Is Better between HP Smart Tank 584 vs Epson L3250
If you prioritize higher print resolution and faster speeds, the Epson EcoTank L3250 is the better choice.
However, if you value higher color page yields and stable wireless connectivity, the HP Smart Tank 584 would be more suitable.
Prabir Mandal is the editor-in-chief of Printer Guru. He is in love with productivity devices, especially printers. His love for printers has made him open this blog where he can share all his knowledge about printers and the experiences he has gathered while using them.
